Sean McCall, Kay Francis, and Emily Bodkin in Whose Wives are They Anyway?
Marquetta Senters in Always... Patsy Cline
Lisa Margolin and Sean McCall in Wife Begin At 40.
Past Performances
Here is an approximate list of productions presented by The Old Creamery in the past.
2018
Murdered by the Mob
Camelot
The Savannah Sipping Society
Greater Tuna
The Tin Woman
A Comedy of Tenors
The Addams Family
Away in the Basement: A Church Basement Ladies Christmas
Theatre for Young Audiences
Fancy Nancy the Musical
The Riddle of Rumpelstiltskin
Charlotte's Web
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
TYA Tour: Sailing the 3 C's
Camp Creamery: The Legend of Blackbeard's Gold
Camp Creamery: Little Red Meets the Wolves
Camp Creamery: Lights, Hollywood, Action!
2017
A Killing at Codswallop Castle
Underneath the Lintel
Making God Laugh
Million Dollar Quartet
Guys on Ice: The Ice Fishing Musical
Footloose
Shirley Valentine
The Church Basement Ladies in Rise Up, O Men
A Christmas Carol
Theatre for Young Audiences
Click, Clack, Moo: Cows that Type
Gruff! The Three Billy Goats Musical
James and the Giant Peach
Junie B. Jones is Not a Crook
TYA Tour: Best Quest
Camp Creamery: Little Red Meets the Wolves
Camp Creamery: A Mystery at Mimsley Manor
2016
Steeple People
Million Dollar Quartet
Shear Madness
Grease
Nana's Naughty Knickers
Winter Wonderettes
Completely Hollywood Abridged
I'll Eat You Last: A Chat With Sue Mengers
Buyer and Cellar
Theatre for Young Audiences
The Frog and The Princess
The Emperor's New Clothes
Miss Nelson Has A Field Day
The Elves and The Shoemaker
TYA Tour: Character Chronicles
Camp Creamery: Lights, Hollywood, Action!
Camp Creamery: A Mystery at Mimsley Manor
2015
The Spy Who Killed Me
The Matchmaker
The Andrews Brothers
Shear Madness
Barnum
Church Basement Ladies in: The Last (Potluck) Supper
Nuncrackers
Billy Bishop Goes To War
Heroes
Waiting for the Parade
Churchill
Theatre for Young Audiences
The Secret Garden
The Reluctant Dragon
Pinkalicious
Jingle Arrgh the Way! A Christmas Pirate Adventure
TYA Tour: Character Rocks
Camp Creamery: The Unknowns Freak Out Roswell
Camp Creamery: Lights, Hollywood, Action!
2014
Frankly Scarlett, You're Dead
Ring of Fire: The Music of Johnny Cash
The Sunshine Boys
Snoopy!!! The Musical
Cash on Delivery
The Church Basement Ladies in: A Mighty Fortress is Our Basement
A 1940s Radio Christmas Carol
Private Lives
The Price
Tuna Does Vegas
Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
Theatre for Young Audiences Main Stage:
Stuart Little
How I Became A Pirate
Cinderella
Junie B. Jones in Jingle Bells Batman Smells
TYA Tour: Count Me In!
Camp Creamery: Merlin's Apprentice and the Deadly Dragon
Camp Creamery: The Unknowns Freak Out Roswell
2013
Death by Disco
TYA: Totally TeRRiFiCC
Freud's Last Session
The Last Romance
Cookin' With Gus
Moonlight and Magnolias
Lumberjacks inLove
Unnecessary Farce
Lombardi
Dial M for Murder
Away in the Basement: A Church Basement Ladies Christmas
Tru
TYA Main Stage:
The Life and Times of the Three Little Pigs
Diary of a Worm, a Spider and a Fly
The Legend of Sleepy Hollow
The Velveteen Rabbit
TYA Tour: Totally TeRRiFiCC
Camp Creamery: Merlin's Apprentice and the Deadly Dragon
Camp Creamery: Calamity Jane and the Showdown at Dry Gulch
2012
Murder Rides Again
TYA: The Very Best Me
The Gin Game
On Golden Pond
Busybody
Shirley Valentine
A Second Helping: The Church Basement Ladies Sequel
The Fox on the Fairway
God of Carnage
The 39 Steps
G.I. Holiday Jukebox
Fully Committed
TYA Main Stage:
The Hare and the Tortoise
Jack and the Beanstalk
Bunnicula
A Winnie-the-Pooh Christmas Tail
Camp Creamery: Calamity Jane and the Showdown at Dry Gulch
Camp Creamery: The Legend of Blackbeard's Gold
2011
Marriage Can Be Murder
TYA: What a Difference a Play Makes
Art
The Dixie Swim Club
G.I. Jukebox
The Queen of Bingo
The Duttons
Love Letters
Suds
The Guys
Boeing-Boeing
The Mousetrap
A Don't Hug Me Christmas Carol
Wooden Snowflakes
TYA Main Stage:
Charlotte's Web
If You Give a Mouse a Cookie
Pinocchio
Raggedy Ann and Andy's Yuletide Adventure
Camp Creamery: The Legend of Blackbeard's Gold
2010
Educating Rita
TYA Tour: Young Abe Lincoln
TYA Tour: The Right Stuff
The Glass Menagerie
Everybody Loves Opal
Rumors
A Don't Hug Me County Fair
Red White and Tuna
Church Basement Ladies
Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
Blithe Spirit
Plaid Tidings
The Santaland Diaries
TYA Main Stage:
Goldilocks and the Three Bears
Miss Nelson is Missing!
Hansel and Gretel
The Snow Queen
Camp Creamery: Little Red Riding Hood
2009
TYA Tour: Problem Solved
Love Letters
Always...Patsy Cline
Partners in Crime
The Odd Couple
Summer Fare: Branson on the Road
The Queen of Bingo
The Wizard of Oz
I'm All Ears: Songs of Disney
Don't Hug Me
Shady Business
The Honky Tonk Angels Holiday Spectacular
TYA Main Stage:
Tale of Peter Rabbit
Rumplestiltskin
Spooky Tales 2009
A Partridge in a Pear Tree
Camp Creamery: On With The Show
2008
TYA Tour: Respect-O-Rama
The Honky Tonk Angels
Rounding Third
The Nerd
Summer Fare: Brett Family Singers
Henry and Ellen
Talley's Folly
Clue: The Musical
I Can't Give You Anything but Songs
Leaving Iowa
Whose Wives are They Anyway?
Ghost Stories
Nuncrackers
TYA Main Stage:
Little Red Riding Hood
Spooky Tales
The Elves and the Shoemaker
Camp Creamery: A Star is Born
2007
TYA Tour: TeRRiFiCC Tales
Dates with a Nut
I Hate Hamlet
Sunday Funnies
Summer Fare: Hughes Brothers
Swingtime Canteen
Complete Works of William Shakespeare (Abridged)
Greater Tuna
Wife Begins at 40
Original Works Readers Theatre: We Are Not Strangers
Noises Off
Ghost Stories
A Christmas Carol
Camp Creamery: Kids' Cabaret
2006
TYA Tour: Imagine That!
Barefoot in the Park
Broadway Serenade
Christmas Cheer
Dates with a Nut
Funny Money
Ghost Stories
Gulf View Drive
Lend Me a Tenor
Riders Radio Theatre...on the Road!
Sunday Funnies
Tuesdays With Morrie
2005
TYA Tour: Twice Upon a Time
Broadway Bound
Grant Wood, Prairie Rebel
Holiday Hijinks, Independence Day
It Runs in the Family
Last Train to Nibroc/See Rock City (in rep)
Mr. Pennypincher Presents
Nobody Don’t Like Yogi
Nunsense
Visiting Mr. Green
2004
TYA Tour: The Lessons of Beanie Biscus
Always…Patsy Cline
Amadeus
Camping With Henry and Tom
Holiday Hijinks, 2004
Out of Order
Perfect Wedding
Social Security
Spitfire Grill
Trio for Two
2003
TYA Tour: So Many Choices
Always…Patsy Cline
Holiday Hijinks: 1963
Painting Churches
Steel Magnolias
Stones In His Pockets
The Foreigner
The Rainmaker
Weekend Comedy
With All My Love, Bill
2002
TYA Tour: Once Upon a Character
1940’s Radio Hour
Always…Patsy Cline
Caught In The Net
Last Train to Nibroc
Lost And Found
Once Upon A Mattress
The Cemetery Club
The Elephant Man
2001
TYA Tour: What a Character!
Anything For A Laugh – The Meg and Sean Show
Beanhole’s Bigtop -- There’s a Cowchip Born Every Minute
Godspell
Home on the Iowa
Love, Sex and the IRS
Over the River and Through the Woods
The Sanders Family Christmas
2000
TYA Tour: Grab 'em by the Tale
Charley’s Aunt
Deathtrap
Home on the Iowa
No Sex Please, We’re British
Nuncrackers
Taffetas
1999
A Christmas Carol with the Creamery
Cash on Delivery
Cowgirls
Harvey
The Toby and Susy Show
Those Naughty Frenchman
1998
A Creamery Christmas Carol
Beautiful Mourning
Cash on Delivery
Cowchip Jamboree
Smoke on the Mountain
The Dining Room
1997
Arsenic and Old Lace
Grace and Glorie
Moon Over Buffalo
Quilters
Smoky Mountain Scrooge
Something’s Afoot
1996
A Christmas Carol
A Tuna Christmas
An Evening with Peter & Zenk
Cowchip Jamboree
Don’t Dress for Dinner
Grey Panthers
Honky Tonk Highway
Little Shop of Horrors
The Boys Next Door
1995
A Christmas Carol
Cotton Patch Gospel
Cowchip Jamboree
Driving Miss Daisy
Forever Plaid
Marvin’s Room
Noises Off
Smoke on the Mountain
The Family Auction
1994
A Christmas Carol
Beautiful Mourning
Cowchip Jamboree
Dancing at Lughnasa
On Golden Pond
Pumpboys & Dinettes
Smoke on the Mountain
The Voice of the Prairie
1993
Cowchip Jamboree
Love Letters
Nunsense II
Shirley Valentine
Simon’s Suites
The Farndale Comedy
The Mystery of Irma Vep
The Nerd
1992
1st Annual Cowchip Jamboree
A Christmas Carol
Alone Together
Driving Miss Daisy
First Ladies of the Stage
Lend Me a Tenor
Squabbles
1991
Arms and the Man
First Ladies of the Stage
I Do! I Do!
John Brown's Body
Social Security
Spoon River Anthology
The Apple Tree
The Foreigner
1990
Come Blow Your Horn
Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Nunsense
One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest
Same Time, Next Year
The Paradise Hotel
Twelfth Night
1989
A Gentleman & a Scoundrel
Czech Tales
Playing Doctor
Theatre in your Lap
1988
Brighton Beach Memoirs
Comedy Club
Extremities
Screw Loose
The Amorous Flea
The Dining Room
The Nerd
1987
6 RMS RIV VU
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum
Pumpboys & Dinettes
Stone Soup and Other Outrageous Tales
The Good Doctor
The Imposter
The Murder Room
Twice Around the Park
Warriors of the Mystic Word
1986
A Night with Marquetta
Midsummer Night’s Dream
Move Over, Mrs. Markham
Theatre Sportz
1985
Diary of Anne Frank
Ladyhouse Blues
Mass Appeal
Not Now, Darling
You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown
1984
A Coupla White Chicks Sitting Around Talking
A Thurber Carnival
Deathtrap
Emperor’s New Clothes
Fantasticks
Here Lies Jeremy Troy
The Wonderful Tang
Wally’s Café
1983
Bedroom Farce
Godspell
Midnight Cabaret I
Murder at the Howard Johnson’s
Short Stuff
Slow Dance on the Killing Ground
The Belle of Amherst
Tintypes
Tribute -1983
Two for the Show
1982
A Gentleman & a Scoundrel
Joseph & the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat
Midnight Cabaret
Once Upon a Mattress
Sunshine Boys
Talley's Folly
The Gin Game
The Last Monthly Meeting of the Bros. Westmoreland
Wait Until Dark
1981
13 Rue de L’Amour
California Suite
Getting Out
Jesse & the Bandit Queen
Jesus Christ, Superstar
Sleuth
That Championship Season - 1981
The Glass Menagerie
The Road Show
Vanities
Where’s Charley?
1980
A Shot in the Dark
An Italian Straw Hat
Little Things
Loot
Rag Tag Review
Same Time, Next Year
Showboat Follies
So Far from China
Waiting for Godot
Who’s Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
Why Don’t They Ever Talk About the First Mrs. Phipps?
1979
TYA Tour: Jack! Be Nimble
Comedy Connection Comedy Revue
The Lady From Maxim’s
Not Tonight Dear, I Have a Headache
Two by Two
Private Lives
Last of the Red Hot Lovers
A Streetcar Named Desire
1978
TYA Tour: The Storybook Circus Fantabulous
Anything for a Laugh: Comedy Revue
Charley’s Aunt
Godspell
Death of a Salesman
A Flea in Her Ear
The Matchmaker
1977
There’s a Girl in My Soup
A Doll's House
The Odd Couple
The Miser
The Mousetrap
Vanities
Twigs
1976
TYA Tour: Gypsy Tales and Dragons Too
Arsenic and Old Lace
Barefoot in the Park
The Good Doctor
Company
Of Mice and Men
You’re a Good Man, Charlie Brown
The Toby Tent Show
1975
TYA Tour: Rimes, Mimes, and Other Nonsense
Butterflies are Free
Lovers and Other Strangers
The Taming of the Shrew
The Last of the Red Hot Lovers
6 RMS. RIV VU
The Rimers of Eldritch
1000 Clowns by Herb Gardner
Inherit the Wind
1974
TYA Tour: The Mime Show
She’s Only a Bird in a Gilded Cage – adaptation of Moliere’s A School for Wives
Fantasticks
Our Town
Plaza Suite
The Owl and the Pussycat
Benefit with 3 one-act plays: Significant Last Tape/The Indian Wants the Bronx/Interview from America Hurrah
The Firebugs
1973
TYA Tour: The Magic Factory
What Makes the World Go Round
A Thurber Carnival: Revue of James Thurber’s works
I Do! I Do!
You Know I Can’t Hear You When the Water’s Running
Comedy Tonight: Comedy Revue
1972
TYA Tour: Stories, Stories, Stories
Two French Farces
Of Kings and Clowns
The Glass Menagerie
Luv
1971
TYA Tour: The Silent Circus
Spoon River Anthology
The Dumb Show: An Evening of Mime
The Doctor in Spite of Himself
Pierre Patelin